So, you’ve got your fresh Florida stone crab claws on the table—congrats, you’ve already made the best decision of the night. But what comes next? The sides, sauces, and drinks that turn your meal from “great” to “unforgettable.”
Here’s your guide to building the ultimate stone crab dinner—the kind that makes everyone at the table think you’ve been secretly taking culinary classes.
🥣 1. Start with the Signature Mustard Sauce
It’s not stone crab season without the classic mustard dipping sauce.
Tangy, creamy, and just a little spicy, it’s the perfect complement to the crab’s natural sweetness. You can make your own with Dijon mustard, mayo, Worcestershire sauce, lemon juice, and a dash of hot sauce. Or—if you’d rather not risk it—order CrabFather’s own sauce mix from CrabFather.com and call it a night
🥗 2. Fresh, Citrus-Forward Salads
When you’re eating something as rich as stone crab, you want sides that brighten things up.
Try:
-
Arugula salad with grapefruit and avocado
-
Hearts of palm salad with lime vinaigrette
-
Shaved fennel and orange salad
They add crunch, color, and that refreshing “I’m still being healthy” energy.
🥔 3. Simple Sides That Don’t Compete
The rule of thumb: don’t outshine the crab. Let it be the diva of the meal.
Great supporting acts include:
-
Garlic mashed potatoes or buttered new potatoes
-
Roasted asparagus or broccolini with a drizzle of olive oil
-
Corn on the cob (bonus points for brushing with herb butter)
Keep flavors clean and buttery—stone crab claws already do most of the talking.
🍷 4. Drinks That Make the Claws Sing
Pairing stone crab with the right drink is like finding the perfect song for a beach sunset.
-
White Wines: Chardonnay, Sauvignon Blanc, or Albariño
-
Bubbles: Champagne or Prosecco if you’re feeling fancy
-
Cocktails: A citrusy gin spritz or a classic mojito
And for those who prefer no alcohol—sparkling water with lemon and mint works beautifully.
🍰 5. Something Sweet to Finish
You don’t need a heavy dessert after a seafood feast. Go light and coastal:
-
Key lime pie (obviously)
-
Coconut sorbet
-
Mango cheesecake for a tropical twist
🦀 Bring It All Together
Whether you’re planning a backyard dinner or a coastal celebration, the key is balance—simple sides, bright flavors, and fresh seafood.
Order your claws straight from Everglades City and let CrabFather handle the hard part. You just focus on what to serve alongside them.
👉 Visit CrabFather.com for the freshest Florida stone crabs, signature sauces, and all the tools you need for your next unforgettable stone crab dinner.
